The FDI data suggest that in the
recent years FDI outflow from
India has increased steadily.
Are the Indian companies fed up of the
indifference? Is the Indian government
showing this in their projex plans? Is this
the reason they are looking for green
pastures overseas, where investment
conditions are conducive?
"Westward ho… or Jai ho…" Formula One dream is finally coming
alive in India. The loud roar of the beastly
engines, the pungent smell of tyres
burning and the mean machines
clocking over 220 mph - enough to sky
rocket every man's adrenalin levels. The
relationship between men and their
machines has always been
extraordinary. No wonder men feel prouder when TATA acquires Jaguar and
Land Rover in contrast to Bharti acquiring
Zain Telecom's operations in 15 nations!
Interestingly, slowly but steadily,
investment from India or Outward
Foreign Direct Investment ("OFDI") has
been mounting persistently, almost in
every sector. The numbers are
astounding. As per the recent data
released by the Reserve Bank of India
("RBI"), overseas investments by Indian
companies jumped by almost 144 per
cent in 2010-11 (USD 43.9 billion) from
2009-10 (USD 18 billion)1 , while the FDI
coming into India dropped by 24.72 per
cent over the same period2.
If the Indian economy is still one If the Indian economy is still one of the
fastest growing in the world, enjoying a
growth of almost 8 per cent every year,
then why do these corporations seek to
venture outside India?
Statistically speaking, India today is the
world's 21st largest outward investor3
with the recent trends indicating that
Mauritius and Singapore4 accounted
for the major share of total OFDI.
Government of India issued its first
formal guidelines for Overseas Direct
Investment in 1969 with various
restrictions on foreign investments.
However, the trend to spend outside
India got a major shot in the arm with
the liberalization of the Indian regulatory
policies. These policies, which were
primarily evolved as strategies for export
promotion and strengthening economic
linkages with other countries, expanded
significantly in their scope and size,
especially after the introduction of the
Foreign Exchange Management Act in
June 2000.
Like it 'takes two to tango', efflux of
investment from India is also a two-way story. Factors contributing to this OFDI
can broadly be classified into two clusters
- one, the "push factors" - which connotes
the struggle and the sore points faced by
investors which force them to look
outside India and second, the "pull
factors" - which are the inducements and
incentives offered by foreign lands
which attract these investors to them.
A key 'push factor' and the fundamental
for any industry is the "ease of
conducting business" in a country.
India, as per a recent study by World
Bank, ranks at 134 in the world5 in this
criterion. Scores of tax and regulatory
compliances (some draconian in
nature) constantly keep the investors
engaged invoking a harried feeling.
Another noticeable 'push factor' is the
rapidly escalating corruption levels in
India. As per the Corruption Perceptions
Index ("CPI") 2010, India is ranked at
87th position worldwide (the highest
rank being the worst), way behind
countries like Singapore (ranked no.1),
Netherlands (ranked no.7) and Japan
(ranked no.17). The situation has only
deteriorated in the last decade, with
Indian ranking worsening from 71 in
2001 to 87 in 20106.
Excitement of entering new foreign
markets and the thought of reaping
unimaginable profits keeps the Indian
corporations on its toes. Apart from
these, a major 'pull factor' is also the
advanced levels of infrastructure and
technology that is available overseas to
an Indian investor. A major 'pull factor',
which should not go unnoticed is the
taxation policy of the foreign nations.
Statistics reveal that nearly one-third of
the money invested abroad as
outbound investment has been in countries investor like Mauritius,
Cyprus, British Virgin Islands which
provide various tax benefits to the
investors. These countries had
successfully attracted the foreign
investors due to their lucrative
investment options and relaxed tax
regime. To illustrate, the corporate tax
rates in India is 30 per cent and while
the same is 15 per cent in Mauritius.
Further, a tax credit up to 80 per cent is
available making the effective tax rate
as low as 3 per cent. Additionally, there
is a blanket exemption from the capital
gains tax in Mauritius.
|
- Source: RBI Press Release
- Source: Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion Press Release
- Source: Vale Columbia Center on Sustainable International Investment
- Source: UNCTAD report 2011
- Source: Doing Business Report of International Finance Corporation
- Report by Transparency International
|
|
|
OFDI is an integral part of every
developed economy and with the
Indian economy maturing further in
coming future, we shall definitely see
more Indian corporations spreading its
wings beyond the Indian subcontinent.
Providentially, India is
coming out very strongly with
solutions to many of the above 'push
factors' like setting up Special
Economic Zones for industry,
institution of Lok Adalats and Mobile
Courts in rural areas, the current
discussions on Lokpal Bill to curb
corruption and several other tax and
regulatory reforms in the recent past.
There is thus, a great hope that such
'push factors' will soon be overcome
and the Indian investor will find better
opportunities in their home-country for
carrying on the business with the
highest levels of efficiency and the
best of returns. Jai-ho! |
|
Ravi Shingari has experience in diverse corporate tax matters
relating to multinational and domestic clients in a wide range of
industries. He has worked on a range of assignments, involving
cross border acquisitions and investment structuring, domestic
tax laws, exchange control regulations, double taxation
avoidance agreements, tax dispute resolution and other
international tax matters. |
|
|
|
Jayant Bakshi has a rich experience in handling direct and
regulatory issues pertaining to range of industries and has
successfully serviced a variety of international and domestic
clients. He has advised many multinational companies in
setting-up their operations in India, cross border acquisitions
and investment structuring, double taxation avoidance
agreements and other international tax matters. |
|
|
|